Newsletter April 7, 2020
Best Practices for Protecting Privacy in the Coronavirus Pandemic
The second edition of Freedom House's weekly newsletter, Keeping Democracy Healthy in a Pandemic, examines new surveillance measures.
By Nate Schenkkan, Director for Special Research
This week we home in on the issue of surveillance. As my colleague Allie Funk writes, governments all over the world have been experimenting with new initiatives that draw on vast amounts of data “to monitor infections, trace infected people’s contacts, ensure quarantine compliance, and map the spread of the disease.”
It is possible that these efforts can help save lives, and there are examples of their seemingly successful use in democracies like South Korea and Taiwan. But there is also a risk that new health-related monitoring programs will create systems and precedents that spill over into other areas and persist beyond the current crisis, entrenching pervasive surveillance and violating individual rights.
How can we stop this from happening?
Read Allie’s piece on how to protect both public health and privacy, and also review this letter that Freedom House cosigned with more than 120 organizations: “States’ efforts to contain the virus must not be used as a cover to usher in a new era of greatly expanded systems of invasive digital surveillance.” And remember these basic principles: transparent, legitimate, necessary, proportionate, and nondiscriminatory. We’re working on a song for it.
A host of great organizations are working to monitor what is happening with democracy and the virus. Here are some key resources we are using:
- The International Foundation for Electoral Systems (IFES) is tracking the impact on elections globally. Its latest PDF is updated as of April 3.
- The International Center for Not-for-Profit Law (ICNL) has a “COVID-19 Civic Freedom Tracker” where you can see all the effects, country by country, of various states of emergency and restrictions on assembly and association.
- Index on Censorship’s “Disease Control?” map documents incidents pertaining to media freedom.
- Privacy International offers a sortable global tracker of technology responses to the crisis.
Around the World
From our offices around the world (or at this point, from our homes around the world), Freedom House has been monitoring developments related to democracy and COVID-19. One of the biggest events last week was Hungary’s passage of emergency legislation that allows Prime Minister Viktor Orbán to rule by decree for an indefinite period. Our Zselyke Csaky has provided answers to four common questions about the new law.
Here are some of the other incidents we’re watching around the world:
- In Russia, an outspoken doctor and medical workers’ union leader was arrested and beaten as she tried to deliver supplies to a local hospital in Novgorod region. (Amnesty International)
- In Uganda, the government raided a shelter for LGBT+ people and took 20 individuals into custody, claiming they were violating rules on assemblies of more than 10 people. (Human Rights Watch)
- In Poland, the government is under strain over its plans to go forward with a presidential election in May despite a de facto ban on campaigning due to the health crisis. The opposition argues that proceeding under such conditions would favor incumbents, and on Monday, a deputy prime minister from a smaller party in the governing coalition resigned over the disagreement, though the coalition itself remained intact. (Associated Press)
- President Rodrigo Duterte of the Philippines ordered police and military personnel to “shoot dead” members of the opposition and protesters who object to his stringent lockdown measures. (Amnesty International)
- After the arrest of a reporter for coverage of the situation in a hospital in the city of Novi Sad, Prime Minister Ana Brnabić of Serbia revoked a decree that had given the government total control over information during the crisis. (Reuters)
- A teenage boy looking out from the balcony of his home was shot and killed by police enforcing a curfew in Kenya. The boy was the second person to die at the hands of the police during the country’s coronavirus crackdown. (Washington Post)
- The US state of Wisconsin proceeded with in-person voting for a presidential primary and local elections on April 7 despite health concerns, after Republican lawmakers won a court battle against the Democratic governor and others who sought a delay or postal voting. (Freedom House)
Heroes: US labor activists
Every week we will try to end with someone demonstrating uncommon bravery during the crisis.
This week we’d like to highlight essential workers in the United States—including medical, sanitation, food, and delivery workers—who have used their rights to association and assembly, even under necessary public health restrictions, to demand better working conditions for themselves and their colleagues. We applaud the bravery it takes for people to continue to work at all in such hazardous circumstances, let alone risk their jobs and face other possible repercussions in order to improve conditions for everyone.
Join us and stay informed!
If you haven’t already, please subscribe to this newsletter. We’d like to continue bringing you updates about democracy during the pandemic, but starting with next week’s edition, we’ll only be distributing to people who have subscribed. (It’s free.) Thank you!